Ulasan New York Edition

Very good

還可以服務不錯，以後可能還會來，洗漱用品全是lalabo，價格比其他的老錢酒店好更多，下次來紐約玩還會住

很滿意，非常喜歡這家酒店，值得推薦。衞生又好。環境不錯。服務一流，設施完善!很不錯。值得試試這個酒店喔。

朋友説位置偏 但比時代廣場和中央公園那裡安靜 如果想安靜就住這 對面一個大超市可以吃飯 買食物 向前台要熱水壺

不推薦，四點才可以入住，歧視亞洲人，早到的話，同樣房型先給了排在後麪的外國人，讓我等了一個多小時！這家酒店是第一次嘗試，也是最後一次！

定了閣樓套房Loft Suit三晚，非常驚艷！地理位置優越（樓下公園裡就是第一家shake shack），附近好的餐廳都可以走路到。房型方方正正，電器設施齊全。大廳checkin等待的時候就遞上飲品，電梯分流非常人性化設計（因為不太喜歡和陌生人共用電梯）。床品和浴袍質感實在是太舒服了！住的25樓，兩邊的窗一邊能直接看到帝國大廈，另一側能看到天際線的日落美景。room service也很棒，唯一不足的是電話接聽較慢（基本要到三次才接）。我們是凌晨五點checkout的，服務員都熱情幫我們拿行李送上車。非常舒服的體驗，綜合感覺比時代廣場的edition各方面都好太多了，已經預訂後面幾天的房間，還住這裏。

房間比較小一點，頭一次住酒店沒有拖鞋，説是派發完了…

服務態度太差

非常棒 非常棒 非常棒

房型很一般

We really enjoyed our experience at the New York Edition. Despite a few drawbacks, we definitely had a pleasant stay. We loved the residential and cozy design. Every space was well executed, modern, and clean. All the staff were kind and courteous. The service was not over the top but still very solid and all our requests were promptly handled. The dining was also solid, we enjoyed everything. Once again nothing was exceptional but still very good. Unfortunately, the hotel is starting to show its age and has not been well maintained. Interestingly enough, the general design of everything is very much up to date but the spaces haven’t been well taken care of and there is a lot of wear and tear everywhere. Everything is in need of resurfacing and a new paint job. Large dings on walls, wear and tear on furniture, peeling and browned adhesive in all white showers. Despite this, we felt that the furniture in the bedrooms and sofas in the room were fine… A refresh in the lobby and bathrooms is needed. Additionally, the front door area was understaffed. The bellmen were great but there weren’t enough on staff. Most of the time there one to open car door or proactively take care of luggage. For some nights costing 1000+ plus this is absolutely unacceptable and something even the W hotel in Union Square is able to do for a third of the price. Finally, while we loved our corner room which had massive windows in the bathroom we thought that there was definitely enough space for a true separation between the toilet and shower (great shower btw) and it seems like the choice was just not made to have that. Overall we did enjoy our stay and would definitely stay here again if the price was right. It definitely isn’t a 1k dollar a night hotel but 600 seems about right considering you are paying a premium for the locations

Great hotel, with excellent service and very nice rooms for Manhattan. I am a big fan of the EDITION hotel style, so there is not much to comment on that because they are pretty much uniform. I love their smell, and when I told the front office team, they gave me the Edition candle with the signature scent, which was a very nice little gesture and also a memory of that stay in my apartment now. I love the location as well, pretty busy area, but Madison Square Park is a nice place to chill a little bit and the Eately around the corner is great for breakfast, lunch, or a snack.

Busy front desk - we arrived at 5 and had plans at 6 - were told we had to wait for a room. They got the room quickly - lots of people were waiting but at the rate for the hotel and that the reservation should start at 4 - I don’t really find this acceptable. Flatiron is a great area to stay.

This was hands down the best experience I have ever had at a hotel. We got married on April 12, 2024. We stayed at this hotel, along with our family and friends, from 4/11/2024 to 4/14/2024. I am SO glad that we chose Hotel Edition on Madison Ave. The customer service is impeccable. Their entire team is sooo professional here. They went above and beyond to make our stay comfortable and memorable. First-class here, and they make you feel like royalty. The rooms are also so nice, and I loved the shower & bath. The bed was so comfy, too. Also, they gifted us robes with monogrammed Mr. and Mrs. on them, which I attached a photo of with this review. It shows they go the extra mile for people, and it meant a lot to us. We love the housekeeping, valet, and all staff we interacted with. Willy, Diego, and Juan were so helpful and friendly throughout our stay. After the experience we had with them, we plan to use this hotel whenever we want a staycation and a few nights away! We can’t wait to go back.