Hotel Barrière Fouquet's New York

We stayed here over the weekend and enjoyed every minute. The rooms are impeccable and so are the linens and toiletries. We enjoyed the Brasserie for brunch which was top notch. We plan on coming back. Service though is not the same as in Paris. The staff needs some French intervention.

I stay at super lux hotels and was excited to add fouquets to my list but I’m sorry to say it wasn’t what I had hoped. I post reviews only when I see serious areas for improvement from a space and this hotel has some work to do outside of the design. Great location. Quiet. The hotel is in fact beautiful and new and well designed and it has a private club feel to it which is nice. Room was decent size and lots of light too. But the rooms are lacking the amenities a hotel of this caliber and cost should have. 1. No steamer in room 2. No complimentary mini bar snacks at all (very odd usually with lux hotels there are a few or the hotel gifts you some in a welcome basket of some sort). 3. The provided in-room hair dryer is so cheap and horrible (all lux hotels I’ve been to have high end hair dryers - Dyson, t3, GHD). 4. Turndown service is barely anything. They move the throw pillows, put out slippers (in the bag but don’t undo it for you) and close the curtains. They put two bottles of water on the same side of the bed. They don’t tidy up. They didn’t take our used cups, didn’t place fresh towels out, didn’t clean up the vanity at all (usually housekeeping will organize my vanity items, wrap up cords, fold towels, etc). Speaking of housekeeping, they are often chatting in the hallways while working and it’s pretty loud and annoying. Also if your do not disturb isn’t on they will literally ring your doorbell at 8:30AM to makeup your room. It happened to me. While everyone is very friendly, the service can be lacking. Waiting 30 minutes for a cocktail or one-hour for food is not acceptable regardless of being in the bar, rooftop, or restaurants. But one of the things is that if you’re not a celebrity or some sort (even D-list or micro influencer) while you get treated very nicely (everyone is friendly) you’re not going to get the same service or speed of service which in NY I rarely see so this felt weird. I also witnessed several times that they clearly save many tables for possible “celeb” walk-ins (they tell others the tables are reserved or they “don’t have enough staff” and then a semi-recognizable person shows up randomly not even staying at the hotel and suddenly the table becomes available. Meanwhile they are turning away paying guests. For over $2000 a night the issues above are not favorable. It’s a cool spot but for the cost it’s lacking a bit.

The room was great and the bed was exceptional. The staff was very attentive. We especially enjoyed the Hydrotherapy pool and sauna in the spa. We were very early and went to the restaurant for lattes. The restaurant manager was kind enough to provide at no charge. The front desk lady brought our room key when the room was ready and our bags were already delivered to our room. The rooftop is very nice.

Hotel is overpriced and overrated. The staff is also incredibly rude and not helpful. Didn't like the hotel decor - tacky and not classic. Also, the room was noisy at night. The restaurant was very expensive and service abysmal. Would never stay at this hotel again.