Freedom05293902502
15 September 2024
This review was sent privately to Hoxton Lloyd. I had no interest in making such comments available publically. However, having sent the email to Hoxton Lloyd on two occassions, each time to a couple of valid HL email addresses, not only did HL fail to respond, there was not even an acknowledgement. I guess some people might be so thin skinned they cant take any criticism. Generally a domain of those lacking in experience. Having mentioned this to someone in the industry, she suggested I just put it up here instead. In the below, "you" = Hoxton Lloyd Some time has passed since our stay, perhaps they have addressed some of the issues raised here. Unfortunately I don't know if they even got my email..... --------------------------------------- We had the pleasure of staying at the Hoxton Lloyd in room 311 for two nights 23-25 April 2024. We loved the design and care that had gone into converting this commercial building into a welcoming hotel space: the design overlay was immense and the mix of new and retained was skilfully executed. The materials and colours were both internally consistent but caught your attention: who knew so many shades of green could be usefully employed in a single area? But….and you knew there would be a “but”…..in my opinion you have fallen for the trap that “form” is so much more important than “function”. The design seems to presume that visually great must make for a good space to live in. Let me give you three (random) observations: - the Barbue bar looked warm and inviting but we could not find one comfortable seat. The box chairs and sofa’s with their vertical unsupporting sides did not make for a seat where we wanted to hang out. Form over Function I. We ended up in the low gold seats. (We would add that the banquettes in the Bremen are much too low too. When my wife was in one of the wooden seats opposite me, she noted that she towered over me despite being nearly 30cm shorter than me…... The seat base of the banquette should be the same height as any accompanying chairs.) - in our room, 311, we had a massive bathroom but a farcically small bedroom which could only accommodate a (small) 1.50m bed. The bed area was so tight, that the clothes hanging unit at the end of the bed took my shins out each night when utilising the “facilities” in the dark. It seemed that a “wow” bathroom (huge but the toilet weirdly centrally exposed rendering the room often a one-person enclave) had been created at the complete expense of a practical bedroom space (where you spend 90% of the time). I realise adapting services and plumbing are tricky in a building of this type, but still it falls foul of Form over Function (II). The end result, in my opinion, does not work. But looks great. Perhaps designers have mugged the pragmatists? - finally (and this gripe you do need to deal with) the staff in the Bremen appeared to think that serving at table was something you do when you have time. It all looked great,
Terjemahkan