Private, Quiet 1 Bedroom in Amityville

Our stay here was good. My high school son and I were in town for lacrosse. The space was just what we needed....clean, comfortable bed, functional kitchen. I took the couch which was small but just the right size for me. *Note, this was not advertised as a "bed", which I was fully aware of!*Just two things to point out. The space you are renting is a converted garage attached to a home with full time residents. We stayed during a very HOT time on LI. 90's during the day. When we checked in the unit thermostat read 84 degrees. There is one wall unit for the entire space. We turned the unit on (it was off when we checked in) and it took about 4 hours to cool the space. The bedroom has no way to be cooled unless you keep the door open. There is a ceiling fan, but the bedroom stays about 5-10 degrees warmer than the space with the AC unit. The other point to note is the neighborhood is very quiet, as advertised. I never felt unsafe, however, had I been a female traveling alone, I would probably not have picked this location.

WOW, WOW and WOW – what a host and place. The host was amazing and greeted us like long-lost friends. The accommodation far exceeded our expectations and was truly superb. The attention to detail in this beautiful place is simply wonderful. We would not hesitate to stay here again and our stay was simply not enough to fully enjoy what this hidden gem has to offer. The area is great and quiet and is a brilliant base to enjoy Long Island and within reasonable distance to New York City. The accommodation was so clean and the shower especially was superb. The outside space was stunning and as with the inside, was beautifully done and well-thought out. We were very sad to leave and can’t wait to return, when next in New York state. Don’t hesitate to book this accommodation, you’ll be so pleased you did. An amazing place with an absolutely amazing host.

Awesome I would definitely stay there when I come back up north

Just Awesome! This little place was perfect! They even had a little Christmas tree which made it even homier!!! Highly tecommend!!! A

Convenient location, clean space The place was just as advertised. It was a convenient location close to the parkway. I would stay there again and recommend to others.

Amityville 23 Cahill The week stay was great. The appliances were modern. The shower was modern as well. The dining area needs improvement The chairs and table were too high and not appropriate for having our meal. Overall, the apartment was great. Thank you.